Proudly Canadian
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 1 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 2 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 3 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 4 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 5 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 6 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 7 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 8 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 9 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 10 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 11 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 12 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 13 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 14 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 15 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 16 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 17 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 18 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 19 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 20 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 21 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 22 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 23 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 24 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 25 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 26 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 27 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 28 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 29 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 30 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 31 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 32 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 33 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 34 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 35 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 36 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 37 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 38 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 39 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 40 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 41 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 42 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 43 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 44 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 45 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 46 of 47
Detached for sale at 258 Andrew Street, Newmarket - 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom - Photo 47 of 47
1 / 4744 locked
Active

$1,379,999

258 Andrew St

Newmarket, ON L3Y 1H2

258 Andrew St, NewmarketListed at $1,379,999. 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom 2-Storey. MLS® N13454810.

4Beds
4Baths
2000-2500sqft
2-Storey
4Parking
$6,846.58 (2025)

What's this home worth?

Get a free estimate for 258 Andrew St

Description

As Featured In The Newmarket 2025 Holiday Home Tour, This Exquisite Custom Built Designer Home Is Situated In The Heart Of Newmarket. Constructed In 2017, This Impeccable Home Showcases Superior Craftsmanship With Tens Of Thousands Spent On Upgrades And Premium Finishes Throughout. Spanning Approximately 2,033 Square Feet Above Grade Plus A Fully-Finished Lower Level, This Property Offers Sophisticated Living Spaces Defined By Soaring 9 Foot Ceilings On The Main Lower Floor. The Main Level Is Flooded With Natural Light From An Abundance Of Large Windows, Highlighting The Stunning Engineered Hardwood Flooring That Flows Throughout. The Gourmet Kitchen Is A Chef's Dream, Equipped With Quartz Countertops, An Island With 110V Outlet, Stainless Steel Appliances And Convenient Walk-Out To The Yard. Adjoining The Kitchen Is The Inviting Great Room With A Cozy Gas Fireplace, Perfect For Family Gatherings. The Formal Dining Room Is A Showstopper, Featuring A Magnificent Coffered Ceiling And Elegant Wall Panelling. Ascend To The Second Floor To Find A Convenient Laundry Room With Vaulted Ceilings, Quartz Counters, And Electrolux Appliances. The Primary Retreat Features A Stylish Shiplap Accent Wall, Walk-In Closet, And Luxurious 5-Piece Ensuite,. Two Additional Bedrooms Share A Well-Appointed 5-Piece Jack And Jill Bathroom. The Professionally Finished Basement Expands The Living Space With Durable Vinyl Flooring, Spacious Recreation Room, 3-Piece Bathroom, And Fourth Bedroom Perfect For Guests. Outside, Enjoy $45,000 In Landscaping Creating A Backyard Oasis, Including Patio, Fence, And Hot Tub. This Home Is Perfectly Positioned For An Active Lifestyle In An Amazing Location. Just Steps Away, You Can Explore The Natural Beauty Of Fairy Lake And Its Scenic Walking Trails. The Area Is Also Excitedly Awaiting The Upcoming Mulock Park, Destined To Be A Community Hub. With Historic Main Street Just A Stroll Away, You Have The Best Of Nature And Urban Amenities At Your Doorstep.

Property Details

Property TypeDetached
Style2-Storey
CommunityCentral Newmarket
Rooms6+2
Kitchens1
Washrooms4
Square Feet2000-2500 sqft
Lot Dimensions50 × 106 ft
Fronting OnSouth
Dir/Cross StEagle St & Lorne Ave
Garage TypeAttached
Garage Parking Spaces2
DrivePrivate
Parking Drive Spaces2
Total Parking Spaces4
ExteriorStone, Vinyl Siding
RoofAsphalt Shingle
FoundationConcrete
BasementFinished
Fireplace FeaturesYes
Heating TypeForced Air
Heating SourceGas
A/CCentral Air
SewersSewer
Taxes (2025)$6,846.58
HSTIncluded In
Other StructuresShed, Fence - Full
Listed Date6/17/2026
Days on Market30 days
Possession60 Days

Book a Private Showing

MLS® Verified · Same-day showings available

Same-day showings available
WhatsApp Us About This Listing

Property Insights

Home Value
Estimate

Listing Courtesy of: LPT REALTY

MLS® #N13454810

TRREBMLS®

The listing data is provided under copyright by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB). The listing data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by TRREB. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.

© 2026 Toronto Regional Real Estate Board. All rights reserved.

Thinking about living in Newmarket?

Explore the neighbourhood guide for Newmarket — market trends, popular areas, buyer tips, and more.

HouseIndex Take: 258 Andrew Street

This detached (2-Storey) is located in the Central Newmarket neighbourhood of Newmarket.

The home offers 4+1 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms.

Features include a finished basement, 4 parking spaces including a 2-car garage, a fireplace.

Additional details: lot dimensions of 50 × 106 feet.

Listed at $1,379,999 CAD with annual property taxes of $6,846.58 (2025).

About Newmarket Real Estate

This Detached is located in the Central Newmarket community in Newmarket. Newmarket is York Region's northern anchor, offering an award-winning historic Main Street, the Upper Canada Mall, and strong community amenities. The East Gwillimbury GO station expansion is improving transit access. Buyers find good value in newer subdivisions while the downtown core retains small-town charm with restaurants and boutiques. Detached homes in Newmarket are in high demand among families seeking space, privacy, and long-term equity growth.

Historic Main Street shopping districtUpper Canada MallFairy Lake Park & trailsGO Transit expansion underway
~55 min commute to downtown TorontoWalkability: Walkable Main Street — car-dependent subdivisions
View full Newmarket neighbourhood guide →