Proudly Canadian
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 1 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 2 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 3 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 4 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 5 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 6 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 7 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 8 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 9 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 10 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 11 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 12 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 13 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 14 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 15 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 16 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 17 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 18 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 19 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 20 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 21 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 22 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 23 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 24 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 25 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 26 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 27 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 28 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 29 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 30 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 31 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 32 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 33 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 34 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 35 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 36 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 37 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 38 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 39 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 40 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 41 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 42 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 43 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 44 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 45 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 46 of 47
Detached for sale at 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes - 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom - Photo 47 of 47
1 / 47• 44 locked
View on map
Active

$1,799,000

1 Merlin (Island M91) Island

Muskoka Lakes, ON P1P 1R2

1 Merlin (Island M91) Island, Muskoka Lakes — Listed at $1,799,000. 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom 1 1/2 Storey Detached. MLS® X13552974.

Possession · seller's timeline

Flexible

4Beds
3Baths
1100-1500sqft
Detached
1 1/2 Storey
$10,937Taxes/yr · 2026

What's this home worth?

Get a free estimate for 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island

Description

Private islands almost never come up for sale on Lake Muskoka. This is your shot.Tucked into Shanty Bay - one of the lake's best-kept secrets. Solid community, epic paddling and waterskiing water, and close to town and the city - yet most boaters have never even come back this far. 1.2 acres of flat, usable land with sun from sunrise to sunset and views in every direction. Deep water on one side for diving and docking, a shallow sandy entry on the other for kids, grandparents, and dogs - this island works for every generation of your family. Same family for over 40 years, now ready for its next chapter. Septic and services are already in - a head start most vacant island lots can't offer. The existing 4-bed, 2.5-bath cottage and bunkie w bath are fully livable right now while you plan your next move, whether that's a renovation or eventually building new. This is the kind of island that inspired Sterling Point - no script required to live it. Paddle it, ski it, fish it.

Property Details

Property TypeDetached
Style1 1/2 Storey
CommunityWood (Muskoka Lakes)
Approximate Age31-50
Rooms16
Kitchens1
Washrooms3
Square Feet1100-1500 sqft
Lot Size11.46 acres (499,198 sq ft)
Lot Dimensions853.02 ft frontage
Lot Size Area11.46 sqft (MPAC)
Fronting OnSouth
Dir/Cross StHighway 169/Villas Marina
ViewLake, Trees/Woods
Garage TypeNone
ExteriorWood
RoofCedar
FoundationPiers
BasementNone
Fireplace FeaturesWood
Heating TypeBaseboard
Heating SourceElectric
A/CNone
WaterLake/River
SewersSeptic
Taxes (2026)$10,937
HSTIncluded In
Other StructuresWorkshop, Out Buildings, Shed
Listed Date7/11/2026
Days on Market95 days
Same-day showings available
5.0Rated 5 stars on Google ReviewsWhatsApp Us About This Listing

Property Insights

Home Value
Estimate

Listing Courtesy of: Chestnut Park Real Estate

MLS® #X13552974

TRREBMLS®

The listing data is provided under copyright by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB). The listing data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by TRREB. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.

© 2026 Toronto Regional Real Estate Board. All rights reserved.

HouseIndex Take: 1 Merlin (Island M91) Island

This detached (1 1/2 Storey) is located in the Wood (Muskoka Lakes) neighbourhood of Muskoka Lakes.

The home offers 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms.

Features include a fireplace.

Listed at $1,799,000 CAD with annual property taxes of $10,937 (2026).